Showing posts with label D - Factual Programming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label D - Factual Programming. Show all posts

Thursday, 12 June 2014

Is TV News a Window on the World?

TV News has to be completely neutral in order to gain its viewers' trust, but just how possible is that?

It certainly talks the talk. In just their opening sequences alone, we can see that various news networks really pull out all the stops in order to appear as unbiased as possible. For instance, in a lot of news starting sequence we get either shots of various world landmarks or some nice globe-based imagery:












This gives the vague idea that we are getting news from all over the world and from all walks of life. We are, but it's still only a very limited selection of the countless millions of events that transpire across the globe daily, so it's tricky to say that this is still totally unbiased already. Also a good thing to note is the use of transparent objects. There's transparent stuff everywhere, in most news networks.

This here is from Five News. You can see that other shape
from behind the first one, so they're transparent.
The transparency is to give the viewer the idea that they are just 'looking through' the network at the stories, and that the stories are being presented 'as-is'. This is probably the most overt argument for TV News to be considered a 'window on the world', as windows tend to be transparent more often than not.

You may be noticing a lot of the colour blue on these images. With the exception of BBC News, a lot of news networks choose blue as their primary colour:



















It's been scientifically proven that blue is an easing/relaxing colour, and it is the reason why a lot of brands and companies use a blue colour scheme, so much so that it's become somewhat of a challenge to guess which shade of blue is for which brand.

Another way that these news programmes try to remain unbiased is with their newsreaders.



Especially in the UK, these newsreaders are mostly steely-faced, plain and to the point. This is to make sure that they do not impress their own opinion onto the stories being discussed and only give the information. We don't see many celebrities reading the news because that would mean that their public personality would be subconsciously associated with any story being read and that would again detract from the news' supposed honesty and transparency.

They also talk directly to the camera, giving the viewer the sense that there is nothing between the readers and the viewer, the stories are being read directly to the viewer.

As mentioned earlier, no one network could possibly begin to cover every single event happening on Earth, so the stories getting shown have to jump through a certain amount of hoops to get on air, known affectionately as 'The Gatekeeping Process':

Firstly, the event itself happens. Then, certain sources of news find out about the event. This could include the police, or social media such as Facebook or Twitter. Even now things are being narrowed down because not everything is posted to social media in the first place, and even if it were, the news can't possibly find and report everything that is posted anyway.

After that, certain stories are valued over others through what is known as the News Values, coined by Galtung and Ruge:

1. Frequency: News networks have a routine; a very specific order of doing things, and if an event happens at the wrong time then it is less likely to be covered.

2. Threshold: The amount of people that an event involves also has an effect on whether it gets news coverage or not, for example a natural disaster affecting thousands will be reported over a smaller flood affecting less people.

3. Ambiguity: If a story is unclear or vague it is less likely to be covered. For instance, the case with Rolf Harris being accused of being a child molester is fairly explicit and straight-forward; it's not likely that people would misunderstand the circumstances here.

4. Meaningfulness: Is the story relevant to the people it is being shown to? An example of this is that the story of innocent man Jean Charles de Menezes being wrongfully shot and killed by police back in 2005 was widely reported in the UK for weeks, whereas in the US it was barely touched upon. This is because it's more meaningful to those in the UK because it happened at a UK airport.

5. Unexpectedness: News networks love shocking or surprising news, such as freak accidents, or a child stabbing and killing a teacher.

6. Continuity: Sometimes stories get elevated to a special status wherein they will be followed for a number of weeks as they develop, like the altercation between MP Andrew Mitchell and a couple of police officers back in 2012.

7. Elite Nations: A story concerning developed countries such as the US will be more likely to get coverage than one concerning a developing country like Baghdad, for instance the Sandy Hook school shooting in the US.

8. Elite Persons/Celebrity: If a person is wealthy or well-known, then things that happen to them are more likely to be covered, i.e a celebrity suddenly dying like Rik Mayall would be reported over someone less known dying.

9. Negativity: Bad news is more popular with news networks than positive ones just because a smaller negative event can affect more people than a positive event of similar magnitude.

If a story fits one or more of these criteria, then they still might not get put out due to legal issues or technical difficulties. Monetary issues are also a factor, as if a story is breaking in another country then the network might not be able to fly a reporter out to cover it, such as what happened with Tiananmen Square, where the BBC got much better coverage because they had more money.

If a story is covered by one news team then unless it is of a certain size then it is less likely to be covered by other networks.

Technical issues during broadcast can also determine whether a story will make it to the audience, as communications might be lost with a roving reporter etc.

But after that, the story will have finally made it to the broadcast, and the audience will have seen it.

That's certainly quite the rigorous selection process. How can we really say that the news is a 'window on the world' if we only see such a small part of it?

Furthermore, does it even matter? Nowadays we have so many different news outlets, both traditional and not, that we should be able to form our own opinions on what is going on and seek out news relevant to us if appropriate.

Is that a problem? Maybe. We might be approaching a social climate in which various groups of people are contained within their own social 'filter bubble', and this is happening already with sites like Facebook and Google, whose algorithms return stories that are relevant to the user based on past history and interest. What's the issue with this? Well, people will eventually be contained within their own ideological and cultural bubbles, and they won't be exposed to anything that opposes their view. This is a real issue as it's important for people to be exposed to multiple sides of an argument in order to form their own opinions and then change those opinions if appropriate.

So, to answer the question, no. TV News isn't a 'window on the world', no matter how hard it tries to be. But in the Information Age, that really isn't that much of a problem in certain respects. Other respects may need a little tending to, but won't be too difficult to fix.

Wednesday, 7 May 2014

The Nature and Purposes of Research in the Creative Media Industries

Research is a difficult but altogether far too necessary evil that is core to almost all creative media productions, no matter how big or small. As such, it's important to understand the different forms that research can come in so that one can be better prepared when, inevitably, a project requires research.

Normally, the first kind of research to be undertaken is 'secondary' research. This may seem like a misnomer, but it means garnering information from existing sources; such as websites, books, government statistics, etc. so it would stand to reason that this is normally the first way people get information. A good example of such research would be if someone wanted to know about, say, the American Civil War, they could look up Wikipedia and follow sources from there and just generally read about the subject. It's secondary because this person isn't actually asking people from the Civil War about it, instead reading what other people have found out.


I, personally, used websites about synesthesia like Neuroscience for Kids and the University of Sussex's research page on synesthesia.

After gathering some preliminary information on your given subject, it's not unheard of to need something a little more specific. Enter 'primary research' which, as the name suggests, is information that you gather yourself, or from 'primary' sources. This can come in many forms, like interviews, questionnaires, experiments, focus groups, etc. I myself made a survey using Google Forms. Given our budget and time-frame, surveys were the most practical because they're quick and cheap, and we could get a lot of different results in a small amount of time. For example, something I learned from my survey was that, according to my results, more people had heard of synesthesia than not, which was a little surprising.

If we had a larger budget and some more time, it would have been quite good to have a focus group, or a test screening after production. A good example of this is Disney's The Emperor's New Groove, which started out as a more serious tale akin to the Lion King called Kingdom of the Sun. However, during production there were numerous test screenings to various focus groups, and the film as it was just did not resonate with the audiences. So, Disney changed almost everything about the film and it became the classic it is today.

This is a prime example of audience research. However, there is also market research that has to be done. Market research is similar to audience research but different in the sense that instead of looking at audience opinions and attitudes, one is scoping out the current market to see if there is competition. Sure, there might be audience demand for a hard sci-fi movie about a bunch of people stranded on a spaceship and audience research would have no problem with that, but then market research would reveal that Sunshine is already a thing, and that the demand is probably sufficiently fulfilled. I did look at finding some existing documentaries on synesthesia for my project, and did indeed find some similar films. If I were producing for TV, I might have ditched the idea but as it turns out these documentaries aren't very well-known, so the demand for a documentary about synesthesia would go on unfulfilled regardless of existing media.

Within primary and secondary research there is different types of data that can be gained, the first of which being 'quantitative'. Coming from the word 'quantity', this is about numerical data and things that can be plotted on a line, for instance money or amounts of people. For instance, if someone wanted to know how many people go out to buy ice cream on a hot day, they could sit by an ice cream truck and record how many people buy ice cream from there. It's quantitative because they're counting a number and not the type of something.

In my research the main quantitative data I was looking for was numbers of people who had synesthesia, which ended up being very vague due to the nature of the condition.

The opposite of quantitative data is 'qualitative'. From the word 'quality', this pertains to data that cannot be assigned a numerical value, such as colour, or shape. For example, say someone wanted to study how people react when left in an empty room. They would probably just sit someone in an empty room and observe what they do. A number can't really be applied to these, so the data is qualitative.

For my topic especially, qualitative data was rather important, as I needed to know things like what people thought the word meant, whether they know anyone who has it or not, and whether it was something they wanted to hear more about or not.

An easy way of finding some information ripe for secondary picking is data gathering agencies, like BARB or RJAR. These agencies' main purpose is to gather data about audiences for other companies and people to use and benefit from. BARB (British Audience Research Board) in particular analyses TV ratings for hundreds of channels, and lists them on their website in millions of viewers per show. That would be helpful for me if I were trying to put my documentary on TV because it gave me an idea of what kind of documentaries people watch and when, giving a sort of blueprint of the most opportune time to air.

For instance, a documentary like One Born Every Minute on Channel 4 wouldn't do so well before watershed even though its content is discreet enough to qualify for being shown before then. However, it might not know that if it weren't for current viewing figures for other programmes of a similar ilk.

So why is this information so sought after? Well, in an industry such as this one it is immensely important to know your audience; who likes what and at what age, depending on where they live etc. Nearly everything that goes on TV is extensively researched beforehand to see if it is actually viable to produce, and then to see when it would be most appropriate to air since every single venture is crazy risky. It's not just audience data either, it's also important to know whether there is any direct competition in the specific space one is after (in my case another documentary about synesthesia) and how audiences are responding to said competition. My audience research was in the form of the survey. I asked questions pertaining to their current attitude towards synesthesia (if they had one to start with), and how aware they were of the subject.

After the audience has been researched sufficiently, one must then tackle the production research. This is all about how viable the actual plans for production are, whether enough funds can be secured to go ahead with production, whether there is enough equipment about to make the production etc. There wasn't really much of this needed for my documentary, as equipment, funds, etc are all pre-decided. However, I did need to research locations in order to find some that were most sensible for each of the interviews in my documentary.

The reliability of a piece of research greatly increases if it's repeated. This is true across all research, and this is no exception, but it's important to note that conditions are important. Some problems with using questionnaires include distribution online; it's difficult to make sure you're getting results from a wide range of different types of people and I don't think I succeeded in this as a lot of people who answered were around the same age; so my results probably aren't very generalisable, and won't be representative of the wider community. There's also the issue in that, when online, people act as they would when shrouded with the veil of anonymity - they'll do whatever they want. Often this means that some people won't take the questionnaire seriously, and the answers may not be totally reliable. This happened in my questionnaire once or twice - I doubt someone actually thought synesthesia meant 'homosexual'. Answers may not be reliable if the questionnaire asks difficult questions, either - a question relating to someone's private habits might cause people to lie. This is known as 'social desirability bias'.

On the other hand, it's entirely possible that people will display demand characteristics through giving not the answers that they believe in, but the answers they think I'd want to hear. Again, this is very difficult, if not impossible to avoid; but it's much less likely to happen with strangers, which is why I submitted my questionnaire to an online forum. Some benefits to that include the fact that I got a lot more results than I would have otherwise, but it's not perfect since I got a more narrow selection of people answering. As such, my results don't necessarily represent the population as a whole, more just teenagers in western, English-speaking countries. If results can't be generalised, then they can't really have any worthwhile conclusions applied to them - I can't necessarily say that my target audience was interested in the concept if that was the case.

SOURCES

American Civil War - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War

Neuroscience for Kids - https://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/syne.html

University of Sussex page - http://www.sussex.ac.uk/synaesthesia/

Google Forms - http://www.google.com/google-d-s/createforms.html

Kingdom of the Sun - http://www.cartoonbrew.com/disney/the-sweatbox-the-documentary-disney-doesnt-want-you-to-see-59467.html

BARB - http://www.barb.co.uk/



Tuesday, 6 May 2014

It's Hard to Explain - Evaluation

It was a lot of work towards the end, but my 3 Minute Wonder - 'It's Hard to Explain' is done!



I'd say it falls into the category of 'reflexive' documentary - Sure, it seems like a regular enough talking heads documentary, but I'd say the use of motion graphics to represent the different forms of synesthesia earns it its 'reflexive' status. Other than that, there's no questions from the interviewer or text (except for titles, credits and illustrative motion graphics). I like it being a reflexive documentary; smaller productions have to rely on experimentation and new ideas to stand out and I tried to achieve that as best I can.

I chose the topic of synesthesia, a sort-of rare condition involving someone's senses cross-communicating with one another because I feel as though synesthesia is not as well-known as it should be, and any small attempt to make it more widely recognised is a good thing in my opinion. More specifically I chose it because it's rather personal to me because I have synesthesia, and that probably provides a unique outlook on the condition.

Camera-work wise, I wanted it to appear as a by-the-numbers talking heads documentary, so I sat just to the side of the camera and had people talk to me directly to achieve the interview effect I wanted. I wanted any and all cutaways to be at the same time as the interview to keep it as contained and integrated as possible, this is the same reason why I used the motion graphics overlayed on camera footage. If I were to do another, similar documentary I'd use more cutaways - some wide shots, some more close ups, just to help disguise those jump cuts a little more.

Sound is undeniably the weakest part of my documentary, which is a real shame because I believe it's just as important as the visuals, and given more time and resources I would put a lot of effort into assuring everything is audible when it needs to be. That being said, I don't think Rose's interview could be improved at all, she sounds the clearest out of the three of us, with me being a close second (I think there was just a little too much wind with my interview). However, the conditions for Liz's interview were not ideal, it was raining and windy and the acoustics in the bandstand weren't great, so the audio quality for the interview was not good, despite my best efforts trying to doctor it in Audition. I think that was the main reason that the audio was No. 1 on the list of complaints about the documentary, along with the music getting louder towards the end and drowning out some of the interviews. I used one or two L cuts, in transition between two interviews as opposed to within one interview, and they didn't detract from anything too much.

Speaking of which, I'm really happy with the music. It was one of the first things to be decided, after I heard it on Soundcloud and emailed the artist for permission. Music is one of the more important things to me in a production like this, and I'm glad I got a song I'm genuinely happy with.

The editing is the crutch upon which my documentary leans upon, in my opinion. Without the flashy After Effects motion graphics, it wouldn't stand out nearly as much as it does. That being said, I'm glad I spent as much time as I did on them. Aside from that, I spent a lot of time organising clips so that they would be in time with the music - specifically, I knew I wanted the music to really pick up during that shot where the visualisation of the week comes out from the back of my head.


When I had the idea for that shot, it was my documentary's stereotypical 'money shot', the one moment where people would be a little surprised or 'wow'ed, and the music picking up at just that moment really adds to that effect. However, I do think I rather threw myself in the deep end as far as the After Effects is concerned with this shot. It just looks slightly tacky in motion and is my least favourite effects shot out of the lot that I did.

Leading on from which, my favourite effects shot would be the one just after, where the week is a ring around my head.


I'm really proud with how this one turned out, and would change very little about it if I had more time to do it. My only dig with it (and I really would be nitpicking) is I would have preferred that the rings cast a shadow onto me, but given my level of experience with the software and time constraints that just wasn't possible. But I'm not too concerned with that, because I still think this shot came out really well.

I was really focused on making sure that the graphics were integrated within the scene in all shots that featured them. This lead to certain little details that I'm unsure whether anyone noticed during watching them, the culmination of which was probably the bit in Liz's interview where you can see the blue '5' whizz past behind her, in continuity with the previous shot.


Aside from the motion graphics, I think I did well in structuring the documentary - it flows well and is clear who's answering what question and when without the need for titles. If I had more time I would probably add more small, candid shots in to just patch up the jump cuts, although as it is they aren't too jarring.

I didn't really include anything too specific with the mise-en-scene. I knew from the get-go that I wanted the whole thing to be vibrant and colourful like many descriptions of synesthesia, yet I'm pretty sure I dropped the ball on that one due to time constraints. Ideally, I would have had at least someone do an interview in a concrete environment with graffiti etc, as that's a perfect contrast to the fields of green that made it in, but logistically getting people out to such a location to film for 20 minutes tops would have been tricky at best.

Overall, I'm rather proud of this video. From the start of the project I was excited to do a video alone because then it would be something that was truly my own, but at the same time I was worried I'd fall behind without the motivation that one gets from having collaborative partners. If I were ever to do it again I'd want to get better-looking motion graphics, but everything else I am happy with.

Friday, 21 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: 'It's Hard to Explain' - Pre-Production

RISK ASSESSMENT




TALENT RELEASES



LOCATION RECCES









INTERVIEW QUESTIONS

When did you realise you had synesthesia?

Could you explain what your synesthesia is like?

Does it help you or hinder you in your daily life?

What was your reaction to learning that you were 'different'?

Do you think people look at you differently once they learn that you have synesthesia?




Wednesday, 19 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: Research - Logistics and Guidelines

FILMING IN PUBLIC IN THE UK

There aren't any explicit laws against filming in public in the UK, in general one or two-man teams should be okay to film, but more often than not (especially with large crews) clearance will have to be obtained through local authorities applicable to that particular area.

LIBEL OR DEFAMATION

For the topic of my documentary I don't think that libel is going to be a huge issue; after all it is just exploring a condition. Since my involvement as a filmmaker will be almost entirely visual, then it is difficult to say anything entirely untrue about someone.

THE OFCOM BROADCASTING CODE 

Having combed through the regulations of the code, there is nothing that particularly applies to my documentary other than potentially misleading the audience, which is something that I will have to make sure not to do.

CHANNEL 4'S VIEWER TRUST GUIDELINES

The Viewer Trust guidelines build upon the OFCOM Broadcasting Code, but with more emphasis on potential misleading of the viewer. It strongly encourages programme producers to make sure that everything is represented at total face value in a factual programme, and that nothing is 'reconstructed' for the camera without explicit mention of said action etc.


Thursday, 13 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: Research - Synesthesia Research

SECONDARY RESEARCH

What is Synesthesia?

'Synaesthesia is a joining together of sensations that are normally experienced separately.' - http://www.sussex.ac.uk/synaesthesia/ (13/03/2014)

'Synesthesia is a condition in which one sense (for example, hearing) is simultaneously perceived as if by one or more additional senses such as sight. Another form of synesthesia joins objects such as letters, shapes, numbers or people's names with a sensory perception such as smell, color or flavor. The word synesthesia comes from two Greek words, syn (together) and aisthesis (perception). Therefore, synesthesia literally means "joined perception."' - http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/syne.html (13/03/14)

How common is it?

'[...]This type of synaesthesia occurred in a little over one percent of the population.' - http://www.sussex.ac.uk/synaesthesia/faq (14/03/14)

'[...]Anywhere from one in every 100,000 people to one in every 5,000 people, but it's difficult to get a good count because of the nature of synesthesia.' - http://www.bu.edu/synesthesia/faq/ (14/03/14)

Existing Documentaries on Synesthesia





PRIMARY RESEARCH

I have whipped up a quick questionnaire using Google Forms to send out, and I've received around 29 responses.

My survey consisted of 9 questions:

Are you male or female?

While a little forward, this information is extremely helpful to finding trends in results. Out of 29 responses, 19 of those were female, which leaves the remaining 10 as male.

What is your age?

From a selection of 11-13, 14-16, 17-19 and 20+, 3 responses were 11-13, 16 of them were 14-16, 8 of them were 17-19, and one was 20+.


Have you heard of Synesthesia?

From all 29 responses, 13 had not heard of synesthesia. With 15 who had heard of it, it's a fairly equal split, but more people had heard of it than I had initially expected.



What does the word 'synesthesia' mean to you?

This was to gauge what the public opinion on synesthesia is, and mostly it's pretty accurate, with most people who had heard of it knowing what it is. There are a couple of misfires (someone thought it meant homosexual, and someone else took it as being an infection of the nose, while another seemed to think it was another word with the same root as 'anesthesia' which is fair enough) but most people who hadn't heard of it didn't guess.

Do you know anyone who has it?

Mostly a resounding no on this one with 17, but a surprising number of people actually said they have synesthesia (6), and a few said they know more than two people who have it (4).


If you don't know a huge amount about it, is it something you would like to hear more about?

Almost unanimous 'yes' here, with only two people saying no.

Have you heard of Channel 4's '3 Minute Wonder' series?

As it turns out, 3 Minute Wonders aren't very widespread in culture. 25 say they haven't heard of it, 3 people have, and one person was too lazy to answer this question.

If so, do you like this short format of documentary?

I threw the word 'documentary' into this question so that those who haven't heard of it have a good idea of what a '3 Minute Wonder' is, and generally people seem rather supportive. Well, those who had heard of it. A lot of people didn't answer because they hadn't heard of them.

Would you watch a documentary about synesthesia?

7 people would rather not see a documentary about synesthesia, but unsurprisingly these are the same people who haven't heard of it or 3 Minute Wonders. The other 22 people seem rather receptive to the idea of a documentary on the subject, however.


Wednesday, 12 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: Proposal - Individual Ideas

Having given the topic of my own 3 Minute Wonder a lot of thought, I have produced what I feel is a rather good idea: Exploring awareness of Synesthesia in the local area, shedding a little light on the subject, and perhaps finding out how many people have it that don't realise.

It would start with a sort of candid-interview format - the question will appear on the screen, and then a few people's answers will be shown. Questions will revolve around awareness of synesthesia: 'Have you heard of Synesthesia?' 'How many people do you think have it?' 'Do you think you might have it?' etc. This would only last a short while, then I would move into the main interviews with one or two people who are confirmed synesthetes. Questions for these would include: 'Would you consider synesthesia something you 'suffer' from?' 'When did you find out you had synesthesia?' 'Does it help/hinder certain things?'

Ideally I'd like it to be very talking heads, with mostly interviews but no interviewer on camera. It will basically be 'expository' and somewhat reflexive since I would like it to be really expressive and visual since that's exactly what Synesthesia is.

The aim of the documentary is to expand awareness of Synesthesia to more younger people around my own age, as to this age group it's relatively unknown.

As for crew, I'd ideally like a sound guy with a boom mic; ADR would be impossible given the candid nature of interviews, and having two crew members seems a little more credible to likely interviewees than  Ideally I'd like an expert in the general field, but I shall have to investigate at the local hospital. Other than that, it's just candid interviews with anyone I can grab who's up for it.

Equipment-wise, I would like a boom, shotgun mic, possibly sound recorder if the camera we're using doesn't have a mic input, camera, and tripod. No props.

Locations are flexible due to the subject matter, but I am placing a lot of weight into the presentation of this, since Synesthesia is a very visual/auditory phenomenon. As such, ideally I would like some rather striking or visually interesting locations to base my interviews, but based on how achievable that is they may just end up at various points around the College.

Tuesday, 11 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: Research - Market Research

If one were making a documentary under regular circumstances (that is to say, not for 3 Minute Wonder on Channel 4) then it would be sensible to learn a bit about the current market for documentaries, and determine when and where it would be most sensible to show your documentary. I did just this, starting by finding out how many documentaries are shown on BBC1, BBC2, ITV and Channel 4 over a 5 day period (Thursday through Monday). What I found was mildly interesting:


From here we can tell that BBC2 shows the most documentaries by far, encompassing just over half of all the documentaries shown on any of the 4 channels over this 5 day period. We can also quite safely assume that there are a lot more documentaries shown on weekdays than weekends. However, a lot of these are shown during the day, or off-peak. While a lot are shown, mostly documentaries are vastly outnumbered by other forms of programming such as drama or sitcoms.

To further my research I went on BARB's website to find the top 30 programs for each channel in the week just gone. For BBC1, only one documentary made it onto the list; Pound Shop Wars. for BBC2,  10 of the top 30 - a third - were documentaries. ITV had one in the top 30. Channel 4 had the most popular documentaries in it's top 30 with 16 - just over half.

Channel 4's One Born Every Minute got 3.18 million viewers last week (making it the most popular programme on the channel), whereas BBC2's most popular documentary last week (Hairy Bikers' Asian Adventure) only got 2.24 million. BBC's Pound Shop Wars was the most viewed documentary overall with 5.29 million viewers, even though it only ranked 18 on BBC1's top 30.

Thursday, 6 March 2014

3 Minute Wonder: Proposal - Existing Favourites

Channel 4's 3 Minute Wonder series of short films is a chance for aspiring filmmakers to get a break at airing their work to the channel's viewer base (which is a lot of people). Despite the fact that no real regulations are explicitly imposed (aside from the already standing broadcast regulations and the fact that it has to be 3 minutes), most 3 Minute Wonders end up being documentaries discussing/exploring various lesser-known issues like illness, or highlighting certain interesting things that are happening in an area local to the filmmaker.

Since we've been tasked with producing our own 3 Minute Wonders, I have taken to watching a few. I've picked 3 favourites:



This Is Our Youth - Carrot Crew

This sort of light-hearted subject matter whilst still retaining the structure and tone of a more serious documentary appeals to me, and the idea is somewhat original and kept my attention. I like the simple back-and-forth between the two gangs, and the sort of observational style really fit the subject matter.




Last Supper

While this isn't exactly the sort of mood or tone I would be going for, I still thought that this one was extremely thought-provoking and sincere. It's another observational documentary since it's just one man talking to the camera (or someone just off to the side of the camera). It's again very simple, and yet it's still able to hold the viewer's attention for its 3 minutes.




Jeff Koons - Three Ball Total Equilibrium Tank

Tate's 4 shorts take a focus group and explore their opinions on a certain piece of modern art; in this case 3 basketballs suspended in some sort of gel in a fish tank. It's really interesting and unique, because it's just one big interview with a lot of different people. It's sort of interactive because the filmmaker's questions are heard at one or two points, but it's mostly just 'talking heads'. Some of these documentaries really tend to blur the lines between Bill Nichols' 5 types of documentaries. I like the focus group aspect, and just the fact that it's a big melting pot of opinions.

Thursday, 27 February 2014

The 5 Types of Documentary

If somebody wanted to really simplify the world of moving image programming down into two forms, then those two forms would probably be fiction and non-fiction. Fiction is more popular and more widespread in film culture, but what is a non-fiction film?



Typically called a 'documentary', these films by definition tend to show real events, with real people. It may be presented in any number of ways, but its definition at its core is its basis upon fact. Mainly, these facts can be presented in any one of 5 ways:

EXPOSITORY

Probably the most conventional, 'cliché' form of documentary, expository documentaries are those that show objective, non-intrusive footage of some event happening, with a disembodied 'voice of god' commentary describing what is going on to the viewer. As is always the problem with voiceover, it has the tendency to be very opinionated, and to tell people what to think. Much like 1958 documentary We Are the Lambeth Boys, someone watching gets the idea that the filmmakers didn't really have a high opinion of the titular boys, and the viewer is encouraged to feel the same way.



Some examples would be David Attenborough's traditional nature shows, or french documentary March of the Penguins (Luc Jacquet, 2005).

As an example of David Attenborough's nature programmes, Life consists of very deliberate and tight cinematography of wildlife, using techniques such as time lapse and and tilt-shift in order to give a view of nature that one could not normally experience. This is then accompanied with Attenborough's revered commentary, discussing and explaining what is happening on screen. It's the narration here that earns these TV specials their 'expository' title.

To be specific, take this one clip from Life in the Undergrowth:



Here, Attenborough explains and provides coherence and narrative to what the ants are doing, while the cameras show in more detail what we couldn't see with the naked eye.

OBSERVATIONAL 

These are quite similar to expository, except from the fact that their values lie solely behind complete objective delivery of an event. As a result, these documentaries lack a certain quality that their expository counterparts possess: the commentary. Observational documentaries try to encourage the viewer to make their own decisions and reach their own conclusions about what is being shown, as opposed to being told what to think. But this being said there is still issues about what the documentaries show. Even without the narration telling people what to think, filmmakers can still choose the angle you view something and select the nicest/worst light. Examples of these types of documentaries include Frederick Wiseman's High School (1968), or Armadillo (Pedersen, 2010).



Armadillo follows a group of danish soldiers as they're posted out in Afghanistan, at the base with which this film shares its name. There is no narration, and the film follows their entire tour from leaving Denmark to returning to Denmark.



There aren't many clips of the film proper online, but here is a trailer. You can see the sort of rugged, visceral camerawork that is involved, and also the distinct lack of any narration.

INTERACTIVE

Interactive documentaries are those in which the filmmaker is engaging himself with the subject matter and the people present. He/she is present on camera, and asks questions / takes part in what's going on. These documentaries normally have some form of agenda to go about, as they are either arguing or exploring their own ideas and beliefs. Louis Theroux and Michael Moore's documentaries are interactive, and in the sense of style one might argue that Dynamo's TV shows are also interactive documentaries.



The problem with these documentaries is that it isn't always clear whether what is being shown is the truth. It's difficult to make sure what you're filming is the truth with this kind of filmmaking as people will know a camera is on them as the camera is much more invasive and aggressive here. That being said, it's usually required to gain a release from people before you film them, and this will always influence the way they act on camera. It's similar to the famous Double Slit experiment, in which the act of observing the photons influences the way they behave. People will always want to protect that which is private to them, and when their lives are exposed to an audience of thousands then there are going to be some parts of their lives that they won't want to expose to said audience.

This being said, there are exceptions. Take news watchdog features that use 'hidden camera' techniques to capture attitudes from people that they would not want to show on camera, which is allowed so long as the person in question is over 18 and that the information being explained is in the public interest.

A good example of an interactive documentary that might use this power to slightly twist the truth is 2012 Academy Award darling Searching for Sugar Man, which supposedly chronicles two Cape Town residents as they try to find a once-popular singer that mysteriously disappeared. As it transpires, they find him living a quiet life in Detroit, apparently completely oblivious of his popularity in South Africa.



Or so the film would have you believe.

In fact, it was later revealed that Rodriguez, the mysterious musician, actually had a pretty successful career in Australia, including tours to sold-out crowds. This is slightly different from the apparently totally unaware 'average Joe' that the film depicts.

REFLEXIVE

This very special type of documentary is the one that tries to break the existing conventions of its genre and call documentaries out collectively on what they are and challenges them. They are experimental by nature, and as such it is hard to define exact characteristics of these kinds of documentary, and the term has become somewhat of a 'catch-all' to describe any documentary that doesn't fit into the other 4 types. As far as examples go reflexive documentaries are the most subjective of all to define, but Isaac Julien's Territories (1984) is a good example. One might also argue that while seeming like observational documentaries, BBC Wildlife Specials 'Spy in the [...]' series could be reflexive too, from the experimental method of capturing footage, and the fact that said method is a primary focus of the documentary.




PERFORMATIVE

The fifth and final type is possibly the most romanticized type, as it has the most features in common with fictional filmmaking, i.e. original score and reconstructions. These documentaries definitely exist to push the film maker's agenda, and are probably some of the most persuasive types in this list, possibly tying with interactive. Examples include The Imposter (Bart Layton, 2012) and The Thin Blue Line (Errol Morris, 1988).









Reconstructions certainly have their place in documentaries, but they're an interesting point because they begin to blur the line between fictional film and factual film. They're normally used when a film is being made about an event that happened in the past where no cameras were present, but they also help to make a film look much more stylized, and more interesting to the viewer as opposed to just having interviews and talking heads.

People's problem with them is that since they are reconstructed especially for the documentary, there's nothing to say that what's being shown is the exact truth, and it's difficult to prove. Reconstructions make it easy for the film makers to change minor details and end up twisting the truth far easier.

I, personally, think that documentaries are allowed a certain leeway in what they're showing, because if they didn't have they would be barred from making certain decisions that might have made a better film. In this sense, a certain contract with the viewer does exist in that there should certainly be a lot of truth involved, but in my opinion it's okay to perhaps simplify or shuffle some things around so long as the main message remains undeterred.

SOURCES

Teach Yourself Film Studies (2009) - Buckland, W.

The Top Ten Observational Documentaries ('SBS') - (25/02/14)